The Next Food Network Star - Top 5
I've been watching this show for the last 4 weeks or so. It's pretty darn good so I'm gonna blog it out to the end. The show's premise is pretty standard reality show/elimination show procedure. They start out with 10 finalists and eliminate one each week based upon performance during challenges. The selection committee decides who goes home (it's very similar to the judges panel on America's Next Top Model).
The five remaining contestants are: Lisa, Kelsey, Shane, Aaron and Adam.
This weeks challenge paired each contestant up with a local Girl Scout. They had to first discuss food choices with the little girl, then decide upon a simple meal that they could prepare together LIVE ON THE RACHAEL RAY SHOW!
These challenges are extremely high-pressure because, not only do the contestants have to make food and cooking decisions very quickly but they often have to perform to a camera or a live audience. And everything has a time-limit! Each contestant had 45 minutes to decide what they were going to prepare and get it cooked once. Then they had 4 minutes of live time on the air with Rachel to prepare it again!
Aaron went first and he did extremely well. He was funny and seemed relaxed. He was not intimidated by Rachael and engaged his girl scout during the entire segment.
Kelsey is one of the youngest contestants and although she has attended a top-notch culinary school she really has no experience to fall back on. She was kind of nervous and it really showed.
Lisa is a very bossy person and railroaded her girl scout into cooking couscous? During her segment with Rachael she lost her nerve and just quit talking.
Shane is also young and childless and did not relate very well at all to his girl scout during their preparation session. While on the show he completely ignored the little girl except for forgetting her name and calling her 'kid' (thank goodness Rachael included her).
Adam was very relaxed, included his girl scout and told several jokes. He did a really good job.
During the elimination session Aaron and Adam were the first two to be sent through to the next round. Lisa, Kelsey and Shane were the bottom three. Lisa was told she needed to work on her personality 'demons' and also sent through to the next round.
Shane was sent home.
The final four, Aaron, Adam, Kelsey and Lisa are going to Las Vegas to be paired up with Paula Dean! THAT should be very interesting.
I can't really pick a favorite in this show. One week two people will do very well and the next week they completely bomb. It's definitely still anybody's game to win or lose. I think I'm favoring Adam though because he just seems to have the most poignant story. He had a family owned restaurant that went belly up. Since then he's gone back to workin in another restaurant. He's explained to the judges how the trauma of his restaurant going out of business caused him to have somewhat of a 'cooking block' for a while. The judges really seemed to be moved by this. I was too.
The Next Food Network Star airs on Food Network Sunday nights at 10pm/9pm CST.
Comments
Oh oh! I almost started posting about this myself! We've gotten totally hooked on this show. We started watching (mostly b/c Top Chef was done) and thought -- eh, ok -- and I think its gotten better and more interesting each week.
I thought for sure they would send Lisa home rather than Shane -- I think she's just too much of a head-case. Aaron comes from my hometown (Camden, NJ).
Surprisingly fun stuff!!
I didn't watch Top Chef b/c I can't pick up Bravo clearly with my cable provider (need to call them about that). I don't watch Hell's Kitchen b/c, I dunno I just don't care for it. I love Gordon but I like his other show, Kitchen Nightmares much better. But I really love TNFNS (too long to type everytime LOL). I love competition shows in general and I also love any opportunity to watch Bobby Flay. It is a really tough competition! I love Guy Fieri and I can totally see how he won since he's just bursting with personality! I'm just amazed at how they get judged on so many different levels. They really wring them out to reveal any 'quirks' in their personalities I guess. It goes to show that there's A LOT more to being a FN star than just knowing how to cook! The only thing I don't like about it is the strange night and time it comes on. Sometimes I forget about it. This week I called my Mom at about 10 til 9. She's obsessed with HGTV the same way I'm obsessed with FN. She practically hung the phone up in my face because she was watching the end of Design Star and that reminded me that TNFNS was coming on.
How cool that you have a contestant from your hometown. I know how that feels from having 3 Idol finalists from mine. It's very exciting and really makes you want to watch more! I love Aaron. I really think he and Adam are the cream of the remaining crop. Both of the ladies have issues I think. Kelsey's smile looks fake like a Barbie doll and Lisa's is downright evil looking! Plus Lisa is just a downright snob...her theme...simply basic or something like that doesn't fit her at all. She's always cooking high-brow type dishes that 'most of us' have never heard of!
I really think that Shane should have gone home first, because of his inability to relate to children (and the horrible way he snubbed that little girl) and also because his theme, passionate french food (or something like that) was nothing but a farce...the guy has never even been to France!
So let's bring it home! Go Aaron and Go Adam!
(is it just me or does following a reality show competition somehow make our lives richer?)
I'm also watching Nashville Star which I'm about to blog about :)
That's the best comment reply ever! :D
I totally recommend catching up on Top Chef when you get the Bravo-thing worked out. We'd never watched any of the other versions of TNFNS (we've been watching more and more FN this year for some reason....) and so I never knew (until I wikipedia'd the show) that Guy had won it. Its interested to see which of the winners have just sort of faded, but he's managed to make it. I think that's great.
We also really like Throwdown with Bobby Flay. The Beloved calls him the hardest working man on TV. I think he must realize that this sort of stardom could be fleeting and he might as well take advantage of it. I don't feel like he's over-exposed yet, though (like RR got there for a little bit).
It's been funny to watch the contestants in this show get better and regress. I agree that Kelsey seems like she *ought* to be great, but she can't shake that trying-too-hard persona. Adam did a great job in this past challenge. I actually thought Nipa had the best hook (not much Indian-cooking on Food Network yet), but she was so meh they had to get rid of her.
:)
Yeah I agree with her they would have hooked another notch in the diversity thing they are going for as of late (At Home with the Neely's and Simply Delicioso) but she just had too much of an attitude problem.
I absolutely love Bobby Flay. He's definitely making a name for himself with his multiple shows on FN AND the multiple restaurants that he owns....I watch Iron Chef America pretty regularly and the challengers almost always pick him...usually because of his New York background...if you've never watch ICA I'd highly recommend it...it's highly entertaining and Alton Brown is an excellent host.
I think RR was overexposed the day she hit the air. She's just so in your face LOL! Some people find her annoying or hard to take but I personally love her. Her 30-minute meals was the first show I ever watched on FN about 5 or 6 years ago and I got totally hooked! I've learned so much about cooking just from watching her.
I love Throwdown too. It's one of my favorite shows! The one against Junior's cheesecake in NYC is one of my favorite episodes.
Here's an example of the real deal.